top of page
for website
27 million


247 thousand
1.6 million

Where to watch

Vision TV on Saturdays, 12:00PM (ET) across Canada

Yes TV on Saturdays, 6AM (ET) in Ontario

Youtube Channel Anytime, Anywhere!

Interpreting Hadith that Portray the Prophet Muhammad & His Companions Badly | Dr. Shabir Ally

Interpreting Hadith that Portray the Prophet Muhammad & His Companions Badly | Dr. Shabir Ally

Dr. Shabir Ally responds to a question about how to handle hadith that portray the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) negatively, such as those suggesting he was involved in unethical actions. Dr. Shabir points out that not all hadith have the same level of reliability; some might have been influenced by the political, social, or theological agendas of the time. This variability in reliability necessitates a discerning approach to interpreting these texts. Dr. Shabir suggests that if certain hadith present a picture of the Prophet that is starkly at odds with his widely acknowledged characteristics of compassion, justice, and ethical integrity, then these narratives should be critically assessed. He proposes that in cases where hadith are found lacking in authenticity or are out of alignment with the Quranic depiction of the Prophet, they might be set aside. This approach is not about dismissing traditional texts outright but about engaging with them in a way that is both respectful and intellectually honest, ensuring that interpretations uphold the moral and ethical standards that the Prophet (peace be upon him) is believed to represent. If you enjoy this video, please support our work financially by: Visiting our website OR Sending an etransfer to OR Subscribing monthly at ► DONATE: ► SUBSCRIBE: Facebook: Instagram: Twitter:

From Our Viewers

I'm a graduate student in psychology and I started reading more in depth of the Holy Quran. I'm constantly making connections between the Holy Quran and renowned theories in the world of psychology. Thank you so much for your all your work. It has helped me to foster a deeper understanding of this peaceful religion!

Melodi E

I’ve often commented on your videos. I have some news. I took my shahadah three weeks ago now and have accepted Islam. My decision was of course not just based on your videos, but they were a great source of information to me, so thank you. My ultimate goal was and is to serve God. I found that I could do that best in Islam. I’m a European white woman (not that it matters) and am compelled to say my decision was in no way influenced by or for anyone else. 


The show answers so many questions and helps me to see the truth of Islam, as opposed to the many rumours that are floating around out there. And most especially in Canada, seeing a woman leading the direction of each show puts to rest all the rumours about how Muslim woman are treated badly.  

Jeremy R

I really love your videos. I am not a Muslim myself but just learning more about Islamic theology has given me a greater understanding and respect for the faith. And the two Dr. Allys have a really great perspective on life in general.

Kyle F

our sponsors


premium uniforms.png




IDRF Logo - tagline-fullcolour.png


Our Supporters

Al Nadwa Educational Islamic Center, Bosnian Islamic Centre, Bosnian Islamic Association Gazi Husrev-Beg, Brampton Islamic Centre, International Muslims Organization, Islamic Institute of Toronto, ISNA Canada, Jamiat-ul-Ansar of Brampton, Malton Islamic Centre, Muslim Welfare Canada, Muslim Youth Soccer League, Muslims of Dufferin Orangeville, Naseeha: Mental Health, Noor Cultural Centre, Sayeda Khadija Centre, The Furqan Project, Toronto Islamic Centre, West End Islamic Center

bottom of page